Soft Almond Sugar Cookies (If at First, You Don’t Succeed, Try Making Them Smaller)

I haven’t baked in a while, and I wanted to do something unlike anything I’d done before, so I found this recipe for Soft Almond Sugar Cookies on the boards. The photo on Pinterest looks like this:


1 1/2 C white sugar

2/3 C butter (cold)

2/3 C shortening (room temp)

2 eggs

2 tsp almond extract

2 1/2 C cake flour

1 C all purpose flour

2 tsp cornstarch

2 tsp baking powder

1 tsp salt

sugar in the raw (I like raw sugar for this, but any coarse sugar would work)


Preheat oven to 350 degrees and prepare baking sheet.


Cream sugar, butter and shortening.  Stir in eggs and almond extract.  Combine flour, cornstarch, baking powder and salt and add to butter/egg mixture.


Form dough into walnut sized balls (I used a small cookie scoop) and roll in raw sugar.  Place on prepared pan.


Bake for 4 minutes.  Open oven and quickly press each cookie to desired thickness with back of spoon.  Bake for additional 4 minutes (8 minutes total).


Remove to cooling rack.  Allow to cool completely.


A few tips:

~You’ll need to flatten the cookies mid-bake, because the cornstarch will keep them from doing so otherwise.  If you don’t they will literally bake in the walnut sized ball shape.

~DO NOT bake longer than 8 minutes!!  They may seem under-baked, but when they cool they will firm up.


I also had a helper in the kitchen today, and it was lovely having someone to add the ingredients and run the mixer.


First we put the butter, sugar, and shortening into the bowl and mixed until they were smoothly combined.

Then we added the eggs and almond abstract. In a separate bowl, I combined the flour, cornstarch, baking powder and salt, whisking them together to get rid of any lumps. Then we added the dry ingredients to the sugar mixture a little at a time until it was all combined.

Next I poured about half a cup of Sugar in the Raw out on a plate.

I used a tablespoon to scoop out the dough and then rolled it into balls which were then rolled in the sugar.

I put them in the oven for four minutes…

…and then flattened them out with a spoon and cooked for four more minutes.

The original recipe cautions against baking longer than 8 minutes, but when I pulled them out, the cookies really didn’t seem to be thoroughly cooked. Not only were they extremely soft, but they were kind of oily.

They were so soft, that even after five minutes, I couldn’t put them on the cooling rack for fear that they would fall apart and fall right through, so I put a piece of parchment on the cooling rack.

The second set, I baked a little bit longer (about 2 minutes) and they turned out a little better, but there was still a bit of oily residue on the baking sheet.

So then, I decided to try making the cookies a bit smaller. This time, I used 1/2 tablespoon of dough per cookie, and that worked perfectly. They still baked for 9 minutes instead of eight (four, then flatten, then five) though.

Very yummy cookies, sweet, with a delicate twinge of almond, and soft, though with a sugary crunch from the Sugar in the Raw. It might be interesting to add actual almonds to the cookie, perhaps ground finely, as well.